Opens in a new tab
  1. Home
  2. Blog
  3. Olive oil
  4. 5 reasons why conscious eaters no longer buy olive oil in the supermarket

5 reasons why conscious eaters no longer buy olive oil in the supermarket

Organic Greek olive oil from Samos | Agastó

Organic extra virgin olive oil from Greece: 5 important differences

Almost every bottle has the label “extra virgin”. Yet there is a world of difference between one olive oil and another. This is what you should look for, and why more and more people are now buying their olive oil directly from Samos.

A box of freshly picked olives in an olive grove on Samos

Take the bottle of olive oil out of the cupboard at home and read the label. There’s a good chance that something will say “mixture of olive oils from the European Union”. That means: olives from different orchards, from different countries, pressed at different times and then combined together.

There is nothing illegal about that. But it is something completely different than extra virgin olive oil from one island, from one family, pressed on the day the olives came from the tree. Are you paying attention to what you eat? Then these are the five differences that matter.

1

Greek olive oil from one island: Samos

Agastó comes from Samos. There, the Charmpis family has been cultivating its own olive groves for generations, using the local Throubolia olive and the Koroneïki variety.

So you know exactly where your olive oil comes from: from which island, from which family and from which harvest.

An elderly farmer picks olives in an olive grove on Samos
2

Cold-pressed within 24 hours from the tree to the press

As soon as an olive is picked, it begins to oxidize. Olives that wait in crates for days or first travel to a large central pressing factory lose their flavor and quality.

At Agastó, the olives are cold-pressed the same day. Cold means without heat. This keeps the good fats and natural substances from the olive in the oil and makes it extra virgin.

It can hardly be any fresher than this. Pressed on the day of harvest, then bottled directly in Samos.
3

Organic olive oil since 2001, without pesticides

The family has been using organic farming methods since 2001. This olive oil is 100% certified organic. No pesticides are applied to the trees.

The bottle only contains one ingredient: 100% olive oil from Greek olives.

4

Extra virgin olive oil with a low acidity of 0.32%

The acidity (free fatty acids) is the measure of olive oil quality. The lower the acidity, the healthier the olives were and the more carefully they were processed. Olive oil may be labeled “extra virgin” with an acidity of 0.8%.

The organic olive oil from Agastó from the 2025 harvest came out at 0,32%: less than half of the border.

5

Rich in polyphenols and full of flavor

Agastó is made from young, green olives. This yields fewer liters, but an oil rich in polyphenols and full of flavor: fresh and green, with a slight bitterness.

Do you feel a tingling sensation in the back of your throat? That’s not a mistake. That’s exactly what good olive oil should do. The dark glass bottle blocks the light, so the oil stays fresh.

Agastó olive oil is served over caprese salad

Comparing organic olive oil with supermarket olive oil

Average supermarket bottleAgastó Biological
OriginOften a mixture from several EU countriesSamos, family Charmpis
PersingUsually unknownCold pressed on the day of harvest
CultivationUsually unknownOrganic since 2001, no pesticides
AcidityIt is usually not listed on the label (max. 0.8%)0.32% (harvest 2025)
PackagingOften a clear bottleDark glass

This is how you recognize and test good extra virgin olive oil

  1. Pour a small amount into a glass and warm it in your hand.
  2. Scent it: good oil smells fresh, like grass, tomato leaves or green apples.
  3. Take a sip and suck in some air.
  4. Fruity, slightly bitter and a tickle in your throat? Then you're in the right place. Does it smell fresh, oily or like cardboard? Then it's old or of lower quality.

Experiences with Agastó organic olive oil

9,7
WebwinkelKeur
based on 414 reviews

The organic olive oil from Agastó was awarded international gold and silver medals and a Great Taste Award.

★★★★★ “Superfine olive oil” — Charlotte ★★★★★ “Great flavor as I had hoped.” — Krishen

Now up to 40% off your order

Agastó organic extra virgin olive oil from Samos

Agastó bottle of organic extra virgin olive oil on the Greek coast

Agastó Organic extra virgin olive oil 750 ml

  • From Samos, cold pressed on the day of harvest
  • 100% organic, no pesticides
  • Acidity 0.32%, rich in polyphenols
  • Awarded with Gold & Silver Medals
€16,14€18,99750 ml
Buy more: 10% extra discount on 2 bottles, 20% extra from 3 bottles (€12.91 per bottle)
Get up to 40% off

Also available in 500 ml (€13.18) and 250 ml (€9.34)

Would you prefer a different size or flavor? View all our olive oils →

  • Ordered before 15:00, shipped today
  • Free shipping from €60
  • iDEAL, Klarna, PayPal

This article is from Products for Home. Acid level according to the laboratory analysis of the manufacturer; values may vary per harvest.

Read also

Voices, gathered around sun-drenched
Mediterranean tables

Thoughts and experiences of people who found comfort, taste and authenticity in every carefully crafted product

Marcel SchotThe Netherlands

Delicious product and gives a Greek holiday feeling. Expensive though, but I placed an order via the Black Friday promotion anyway.

Michael vd vlietThe Netherlands

It's really super delicious

Anya NieuwenhuijsThe Netherlands

Delicious olive oil... Pine nut honey and a Beewax lip balm. All pure natural from Samos with good quality. Worth the effort 💙

Roelie ViergeverThe Netherlands

Great delicious products. Always well packaged.

Said BoubassThe Netherlands

The goodies so far. Great

SandraThe Netherlands

I have ordered several times; good delivery and of course delicious lemonade

Els Kuiper-KuijlThe Netherlands

I have ordered it several times, but it still tastes delicious. We really enjoy it.

Anita TheunissenThe Netherlands

As last time, delivered quickly and well packaged.

Paul SaldenThe Netherlands

People who are thinking along the same lines.

Joke VlasblomThe Netherlands

Delicious syrups and fantastic delicious pine honey and olive oil are received👌 What stands out most are the honest, pure, refined flavors of the products

Patrick HermesThe Netherlands

Super fast delivery and delicious products

Irene ManneveldThe Netherlands

Always refreshing with holiday memories in the background

Jim AidoundThe Netherlands

Super delicious drink 😋

André HarmsThe Netherlands

Top products

Stefan CnossenThe Netherlands

Good and fast delivery of beautiful products

Janny den Braber-VerschurenThe Netherlands

Really a very nice company. Email contact is answered immediately. And they provide good solutions. I am so happy with the gia giamas!

Petra VersteegThe Netherlands

What I have here is delicious

Florence ZaalbergThe Netherlands

Delicious fresh lemonades! Also great to drink unsweetened on ice.

Hans van BeersThe Netherlands

So far, only the honey, very delicious! The delivery of the order was well-organized.

Karim AssedaheThe Netherlands

What a sublime flavor. Wow. Definitely a must-try.

Discover Instagram

  • Gia giamas in a 420ml glass

Bring the essence of the
Mediterranean life into your home

Discover carefully crafted flavors inspired by timeless coastal traditions—from golden honey and hand-picked olives to refreshing natural juices for every moment of the day.

See more
Three fresh Greek juices raised together
The rating of www.productsforhome.nl at WebwinkelKeur Reviews 9.7/10 is based on 432 reviews.