What is extra virgin olive oil and how do you recognize genuine quality?

Extra virgin olive oil is the highest quality olive oil there is. The oil is obtained from fresh olives through the first cold pressing and may not be chemically processed. This way, flavor, aroma and healthy substances are optimally preserved.
Yet not every olive oil labeled “extra virgin” is actually top quality. In this article we explain step by step what extra virgin olive oil is exactly, why quality is so important and how to recognize genuine quality.
Extra virgin olive oil is cold-pressed olive oil from the first pressing, with an acidity of at most 0.8%. The lower the acidity and the fresher the olives, the higher the quality and the antioxidant content.
What does “extra virgin” mean exactly?
The term extra virgin is legally protected. To be able to bear this name, olive oil must meet strict requirements:
- Obtained via mechanical pressing
- First cold press (without heating)
- No refining or chemical treatment
- Maximum acidity of 0,8%
- No odor or taste abnormalities
In practice: The lower the acidity, the better the oil. High-quality olive oil often falls well below this limit.
With top-quality extra virgin olive oil, such as the oil we produce at Agasto, the acidity is around 0,32%, which indicates extremely fresh olives and careful processing.
Why is extra virgin olive oil healthier than regular olive oil?
The big difference lies in what is preserved. Extra virgin olive oil naturally contains:
- Monounsaturated fatty acids
- Polyphenols (powerful antioxidants)
- Vitamin E
These substances:
- Support the heart and blood vessels
- Have an anti-inflammatory effect
- Protect cells against oxidative stress
With refined or highly heated olive oil, many of these substances are lost.
The importance of young olives
Not only how you press matters, but also when you harvest. Olive oil made from young, green olives:
- Contains more antioxidants
- Has a more intense flavor
- Often slightly bitter and peppery (a good sign)
The downside: young olives yield less oil . That is why mass producers often choose riper olives: cheaper, but less nutritious. At Agasto we deliberately work with young green olives, because quality and nutritional value come first.
How do you recognize genuine quality extra virgin olive oil?
You can’t recognize good extra virgin olive oil by its marketing, but by these characteristics:
1. Low acidity
- Legally: max. 0.8%
- High-quality oil: often < 0.5%
- Top quality: around 0.3%
2. First cold press
This means that the oil:
- Is pressed without heating
- Has not lost any quality
3. Taste and smell
Genuine quality smells:
- Fresh
- Fruity
- Sometimes slightly grassy
The taste is:
- Mildly bitter
- Slightly peppery at the back of the throat
Bitterness and pepperiness are not flaws, but signs of antioxidants.
4. Origin is clear
Good producers are transparent about:
- Country and region
- Harvest time
- Production method
5. Dark packaging
Dark glass or tin protects the oil from light and oxidation.
What is the difference between regular olive oil and extra virgin olive oil?
| Extra virgin olive oil | Regular olive oil |
|---|---|
| Cold pressed | Often refined |
| Many antioxidants | Fewer nutrients |
| Rich flavor | Neutral taste |
| Low acidity | Higher acidity |
Can you fry in extra virgin olive oil?
Yes, You can fry quite well in extra virgin olive oil. Thanks to:
- Antioxidants
- Low acidity
- Natural stability
good extra virgin olive oil is suitable for:
- Frying at low to medium-high temperatures
- Stir-frying
- Vegetables, fish and potatoes
In addition, extra virgin olive oil is perfect for cold use, such as on salads or bread Agasto extra virgin olive oil is suitable for both hot and cold use, without any loss of quality.
Extra virgin or extra virgin organic?
The difference lies in the cultivation method. Organic extra virgin olive oil:
- Grown without pesticides
- Respects the soil and nature
- Often even purer in taste
At Agasto we produce both:
- Extra virgin olive oil
- Extra virgin organic olive oil
Both with:
- First cold press
- Hand harvesting
- Very low acidity
Why awards say something about quality
International awards such as Great Taste Awards and Gold & Silver medals are awarded by independent juries based on:
- Flavor
- Aroma
- Balance
- Purity
They are not a marketing trick, but an objective confirmation of quality.
Summary: What should you look out for in extra virgin olive oil?
Good extra virgin olive oil:
- Is cold pressed (first pressing)
- Has a low acidity (well below 0.8%)
- Is made from young olives
- Contains many antioxidants
- Has a fresh, slightly bitter taste
- Has a transparent origin
Once you taste the difference, most people don't want to go back.
Want to know more?
In our next articles we will go into more detail about:
-
The health benefits of extra virgin olive oil
-
Frying and cooking with extra virgin olive oil
-
How to choose the best olive oil
-
Why Greek olive oil is so highly regarded worldwide













